Quick note before we start: This article provides general educational information and does not constitute financial, investment, tax, or legal advice. It does not consider your objectives, financial situation, or risk tolerance. Consider consulting a qualified professional before making investment decisions.
This is Part 2 of a series about simplicity in investing. Read Part 1: Simple Investing in Canada—Why Less Can Be More.
There is something strangely addictive about trying to build the perfect investment portfolio.
You find an ETF. Then another. You compare their fees, historical returns, holdings, geographic exposure, and tax treatment. You discover factor investing. Then small-cap value. Then momentum. Then quality.
Before long, you are wondering whether each factor should represent 5%, 10%, or 15% of your portfolio.
Investing has quietly become a research project.
I know because I have done it. For a long time, I thought the next improvement to my portfolio was always just around the corner.
Eventually, I realized that the problem was not that I had failed to find the perfect portfolio.
The problem was that I was still looking for one.
Key takeaways
- The perfect investment portfolio does not exist because every portfolio involves trade-offs.
- A portfolio that looks superior in a backtest may be difficult to maintain when its strategy underperforms.
- Historical performance can help you understand risk, but it cannot identify the future winner.
- Behaviour is part of portfolio construction. A theoretically excellent portfolio you abandon under pressure is no longer excellent for you.
- A good-enough portfolio should fit your goals, risk profile, time horizon, and need for simplicity.
- A meaningful change in your circumstances can justify modifying a portfolio. Discovering another interesting ETF usually does not.
- You do not need to outperform every other portfolio. You need a reasonable chance of reaching your own goals.
What would a perfect investment portfolio need to do?
A truly perfect portfolio would have to provide everything an investor wants without requiring any compromise.
It would need to offer:
- high returns;
- low volatility;
- protection during market declines;
- protection against inflation;
- broad diversification;
- minimal fees;
- perfect tax efficiency;
- steady income;
- easy access to the money;
- no complicated maintenance;
- and no uncomfortable periods of underperformance.
No portfolio can deliver all of these things at the same time.
Want more potential growth? You will generally need to accept more uncertainty and larger declines.
Want less short-term volatility? You may need to accept a lower expected return.
Want guaranteed access to your principal? You will likely give up some long-term growth potential.
Want more exposure to a particular factor or sector? You will become more dependent on that part of the market.
Want a portfolio customized across several accounts? You may create more opportunities for tax efficiency, but also more work.
Every portfolio solves some problems while accepting others.
That is why the useful question is rarely:
What is the perfect investment portfolio?
A better question is:
What is a reasonable portfolio for my situation that I can continue following?
Portfolio construction is a series of trade-offs
The main portfolio characteristics are connected. Improving one can weaken another.
| Portfolio characteristic | What you may gain | What you may need to accept |
|---|---|---|
| More equities | Greater long-term growth potential | Larger and more frequent declines |
| More bonds or cash | Greater short-term stability | Lower expected long-term growth |
| More international diversification | Less dependence on one country | Periods when foreign markets trail Canada |
| More Canadian investments | Familiarity and potential tax benefits | Greater concentration in a small market |
| More factor exposure | A chance of earning a factor premium | Long periods of underperformance |
| More funds | Greater control over individual allocations | More decisions and rebalancing |
| One all-in-one fund | Simplicity and automatic rebalancing | Less control over each component |
| More trading | Faster changes to the portfolio | Costs, taxes, and behavioural risk |
A portfolio can be well designed without being best in every category.
The challenge is deciding which trade-offs support your objectives and which ones only make the portfolio more difficult to manage.
Why searching for the perfect portfolio is so appealing
There is always another ETF
Suppose you build a diversified portfolio today.
Six months later, you discover another ETF with a slightly lower fee, different geographic exposure, or stronger historical performance. You begin wondering whether you should switch.
Then another ETF appears.
And another.
There are funds covering almost every investment idea: broad markets, sectors, dividends, low volatility, small companies, value, momentum, quality, covered calls, commodities, cryptocurrencies, and countless combinations.
The abundance of choices creates the impression that one particular combination must be the best.
But the more you learn about investing, the more things you discover that you could change. That does not mean every possible change represents progress.
More investment knowledge can improve your decisions. It can also give you more reasons to interfere with a reasonable plan.
Better-looking numbers feel like evidence
If one portfolio earned more than another during a historical period, it is tempting to treat that result as proof of superiority.
A higher backtested return looks objective. A smoother chart feels safer. A better risk-adjusted result appears to settle the question.
But those numbers describe a period that has already happened. They do not reveal which portfolio will perform best during your own investment horizon.
The portfolio that wins can change when you adjust:
- the starting date;
- the ending date;
- the countries included;
- the currency used;
- the rebalancing schedule;
- the contribution dates;
- the treatment of fees and taxes;
- or the period being measured.
A portfolio can look exceptional in one backtest and ordinary in another.
Why backtests can mislead investors
Backtesting is useful. It can help you understand how different asset allocations behaved, how severe past declines were, and how long certain strategies underperformed.
The problem begins when a backtest is treated as a prediction.
Historical performance is not a promise
A strategy that performed extremely well over the previous 20 years may underperform over the next 10.
A market that recently dominated global returns may become one of the weaker markets during the next cycle.
An allocation that looks obvious in hindsight may have been emotionally difficult to hold while its disappointing period was happening.
A backtest tells you what occurred under one historical sequence. It cannot tell you what will happen next.
Backtests can hide the experience of holding the strategy
A chart compresses years of uncertainty into a smooth line.
You can look at the final result of a strategy and see that it eventually recovered. The investor living through that period did not know when—or whether—that recovery would arrive.
They experienced:
- negative headlines;
- prolonged underperformance;
- doubts about the strategy;
- comparisons with better-performing portfolios;
- pressure to change;
- and years without knowing how the story would end.
That emotional experience cannot be fully represented by the final annualized return.
A strategy can be designed around the past
With enough funds, factors, allocation choices, and historical data, it is possible to create a portfolio that would have performed extremely well during a selected period.
But every added decision introduces another opportunity to fit the portfolio to historical conditions that may not repeat.
The most impressive backtest may therefore reflect successful hindsight rather than a durable plan.
The portfolio that wins on paper can lose in real life
Consider two hypothetical portfolios:
| Characteristic | Portfolio A | Portfolio B |
|---|---|---|
| Backtested return | Higher | Slightly lower |
| Complexity | High | Low |
| Number of holdings | Many | Few |
| Rebalancing requirements | Detailed | Straightforward |
| Confidence in the strategy | Moderate | High |
| Likelihood of maintaining it | Uncertain | High |
Which portfolio is better?
There is not enough information to give a mathematical answer. However, an important question is missing from the table:
What happens if Portfolio A becomes uncomfortable enough that you abandon it?
A theoretically superior portfolio that you sell after it underperforms is no longer superior in practice.
This is why behaviour is part of portfolio construction.
Your portfolio is not merely a collection of expected returns, correlations, and standard deviations. It is a strategy you must continue holding while markets challenge your confidence.
If additional complexity makes you more likely to interfere, that complexity has a cost even when it does not appear in the fund’s management expense ratio.
You do not need to win every comparison
I used to compare portfolios as though investing were a competition.
If Portfolio A had a higher historical return than Portfolio B, then Portfolio A was “better.”
But personal investing does not work that way.
Imagine that you own a low-cost, globally diversified portfolio appropriate for your risk profile. You later discover another portfolio that would have earned an additional 0.5% per year during a selected historical period.
Does that make your portfolio bad?
No. It means another portfolio produced a better result during that particular period.
You do not need to beat every investor. You do not need to own the best-performing ETF every year. You do not need to construct the portfolio that would have won during the previous decade.
You need a strategy that gives you a reasonable chance of reaching your goals without requiring more risk or complexity than you can manage.
Investing is not a competition against every other portfolio.
Why consistently identifying the winner is difficult
Professional investment managers have research teams, specialized technology, extensive market data, and far more time than the average individual investor.
Even with those resources, consistently outperforming broad benchmarks is difficult.
The SPIVA Canada Year-End 2025 scorecard found that an average of more than 85% of Canadian active funds underperformed their respective benchmarks in 2025 across the categories measured. Underperformance generally became more common over longer periods.
The Canada Persistence Scorecard provides another useful perspective.
Among 169 funds that ranked in the top quartile of their categories at the end of 2021, only one remained in the top quartile during each of the following four years.
This does not prove that a simple portfolio will always outperform a complex one. It does not prove that active management can never succeed.
It demonstrates how difficult it is to identify tomorrow’s winners by looking at yesterday’s results.
That evidence should make us humble about our ability to recognize the perfect investment portfolio in advance.
What makes a portfolio “good enough”?
Good enough does not mean careless, poorly diversified, expensive, or unsuitable.
A good-enough portfolio has already addressed the decisions that matter most.
1. It has a clear purpose
You know whether the money is intended for retirement, financial independence, education, a future purchase, or another goal.
The portfolio’s risk and time horizon reflect that purpose.
2. Its risk is appropriate
The allocation reflects both:
- your willingness to tolerate fluctuations; and
- your financial ability to absorb losses without disrupting the goal.
If you are uncertain, review How to Find Your Investment Risk Profile in Canada.
3. It is broadly diversified
The portfolio is not dependent on one company, sector, country, or investment style.
Diversification cannot eliminate losses, but it can reduce the damage caused by being wrong about one concentrated idea.
See How to Diversify Your Portfolio in Canada for a more detailed framework.
4. Its costs are reasonable
The portfolio avoids unnecessary management fees, excessive trading, frequent currency conversions, and other costs that do not provide enough value.
The cheapest possible portfolio is not automatically the best, but costs should be understood and justified.
5. You understand what you own
You can explain:
- what each holding contains;
- why it belongs in the portfolio;
- what risk it introduces;
- how it contributes to the goal;
- and what would justify changing it.
6. You can maintain it
You know how new contributions will be invested and when the portfolio will be rebalanced or reviewed.
Its maintenance requirements fit the amount of time and attention you are willing to provide.
7. You can continue holding it when it disappoints you
Every reasonable portfolio will eventually underperform another reasonable portfolio.
A strategy is only useful if you can continue following it through those periods.
A good-enough portfolio test
Before changing your portfolio, ask these questions:
| Question | A reassuring answer |
|---|---|
| Does the portfolio match my goal and time horizon? | Yes |
| Is its risk appropriate for my situation? | Yes |
| Is it broadly diversified? | Yes |
| Are its costs reasonable and understood? | Yes |
| Can I explain the purpose of every holding? | Yes |
| Do I know how and when to rebalance it? | Yes |
| Could I continue holding it through a major decline? | Probably |
| Has something meaningful in my life or plan changed? | No |
If the portfolio passes this test, it may already be doing its job.
The existence of another interesting fund does not create a problem that needs to be solved.
When changing your portfolio may be justified
Accepting a good-enough portfolio does not mean refusing to make necessary changes.
A review may be appropriate when:
- your financial goal changes;
- your time horizon becomes shorter or longer;
- your income or employment becomes less stable;
- your need for liquidity changes;
- your tolerance or capacity for risk changes;
- the portfolio is poorly diversified;
- your fees are unreasonably high;
- a fund changes its mandate or structure;
- your tax or account situation changes;
- the portfolio has become unnecessarily difficult to manage;
- or your holdings no longer match your written investment plan.
These are changes to the investor, the goal, or the investment itself.
They are different from changing because:
- another fund recently performed better;
- a new ETF was launched;
- a financial personality prefers another allocation;
- one region has underperformed;
- a backtest produced a better result;
- or you feel pressure to do something after reading market news.
A good review asks whether your plan still fits your life. It does not begin by searching for whatever performed best recently.
The Canadian account does not determine the portfolio
Canadian investors often use several account types, including:
- TFSAs;
- RRSPs;
- FHSAs;
- RESPs;
- and non-registered accounts.
These accounts affect contribution limits, deductions, withdrawals, grants, and taxation. They do not automatically determine the appropriate investment strategy.
The same broad asset allocation may sometimes be used across several accounts, while more advanced investors may place different assets in different accounts for tax reasons.
Neither approach is universally perfect.
For many investors, maintaining a clear and consistent portfolio across their accounts may be more valuable than pursuing a complicated asset-location strategy they do not understand or cannot maintain.
Tax efficiency matters, especially as a portfolio grows. It should be weighed against the additional work, trading, and possibility of errors created by a more complex structure.
What should you optimize instead?
The search for perfection can turn a reasonable investment plan into a continuous decision-making exercise.
Instead of repeatedly asking, “What investment could make my portfolio better?” consider the parts of your financial life you can influence more directly.
Savings rate
How much new money enters the portfolio?
Increasing consistent contributions may have a greater effect than switching between similar funds.
Asset allocation
How much risk are you taking?
The balance among stocks, bonds, and cash can have a much greater effect on portfolio behaviour than small differences between comparable ETFs.
Diversification
How dependent are you on one company, sector, country, currency, or strategy?
Costs
How much of your return is lost to management fees, trading, advice, currency conversion, and taxes?
Tax and account decisions
Are you using your TFSA, RRSP, FHSA, RESP, or non-registered accounts appropriately for your circumstances?
Discipline
Can you continue following the strategy during a bear market or a long period of underperformance?
Time in the market
Are you allowing your contributions and investment returns enough time to compound?
If you frequently wait for the right moment to invest, read Why Time in the Market Beats Timing the Market.
Notice what is missing from this list.
Finding the next ETF is not usually the most important improvement available.
Good enough is not a failure
There is something psychologically uncomfortable about accepting a good-enough portfolio.
We are taught to compare and optimize: the best phone, the best car, the best mortgage rate, the best rewards card.
Why would we not search for the best portfolio?
Because investing contains too many unknowns. The future is uncertain, and the portfolio that will eventually produce the highest return cannot be identified in advance.
A portfolio can be excellent without being optimal.
In fact, good enough can become an advantage when it helps you:
- make regular contributions;
- avoid unnecessary trading;
- understand what you own;
- rebalance consistently;
- ignore short-term noise;
- and remain invested during difficult periods.
You do not need to improve something merely because improvement seems possible.
The goal is not to find the portfolio that looks best on paper. The goal is to build one you can live with.
Frequently asked questions
Does a perfect investment portfolio exist?
No portfolio can maximize return, stability, diversification, liquidity, tax efficiency, simplicity, and certainty simultaneously. Every portfolio involves trade-offs. The appropriate objective is to find a portfolio suited to your goals, risk profile, time horizon, and financial circumstances.
How do I know whether my portfolio is good enough?
A portfolio may be good enough if it matches your goals and risk profile, is broadly diversified, has reasonable costs, is understandable, and can be maintained through difficult markets. Good enough does not mean ignoring a genuine flaw or accepting an unsuitable level of risk.
Should I switch to an ETF with better historical returns?
Not automatically. Historical returns describe the past and can depend heavily on the period measured. Before switching, compare the funds’ holdings, risk, diversification, costs, tax consequences, and roles in your plan.
Is a more complicated portfolio likely to earn a higher return?
Not necessarily. Additional funds can provide useful exposure, but they can also create overlap, costs, maintenance work, and behavioural risk. Complexity should have a clear purpose.
Does accepting a good-enough portfolio mean I should never change it?
No. A change may be justified when your goals, time horizon, finances, risk capacity, tax situation, or investments materially change. A new product or a period of underperformance does not automatically justify abandoning the plan.
How often should I review my portfolio?
A planned annual review may be sufficient for many long-term investors, along with an additional review after a meaningful life or financial change. Monitoring it constantly can create pressure to react to ordinary market movements.
What is the difference between reviewing and tinkering?
Reviewing compares your portfolio with your goals and written plan. Tinkering changes the portfolio in response to new ideas, recent performance, forecasts, or discomfort even though the original plan remains appropriate.
The takeaway
The perfect investment portfolio does not exist.
There will always be another ETF, strategy, factor, or allocation that looks better during a selected historical period. You do not need to own all of them.
Build a diversified portfolio that fits your goals, risk profile, time horizon, and willingness to maintain it. Make the important decisions carefully. Establish clear reasons for changing the plan.
Then give yourself permission to stop searching.
Good investing is not necessarily about finding the perfect portfolio.
Sometimes, it is about recognizing when you already have a good-enough one.
Next step
Write down:
- why you chose your current portfolio;
- its target asset allocation;
- the purpose of every holding;
- how and when you will rebalance;
- and the circumstances that would justify changing it.
Then give yourself one rule:
Do not change the plan merely because you found something interesting. Change it when your circumstances, objectives, or the investments themselves have meaningfully changed.
Part 3 explores what happened when investing became too much and why I eventually stopped tinkering with my portfolio.
Related articles
- Simple Investing in Canada: Why Less Can Be More
- When Investing Becomes Too Much: Why I Stopped Tinkering
- How to Find Your Investment Risk Profile in Canada
- How to Diversify Your Portfolio in Canada
- All-in-One ETFs in Canada: How to Choose the Right Portfolio
- The Psychology of Investing: How to Stay the Course
- Why Time in the Market Beats Timing the Market